devActivitydevActivity Logo

Streamlining AI Assistance: Overcoming Copilot's File Reading Hurdles for Better Project Planning

In the fast-paced world of software development, AI assistants like GitHub Copilot are becoming indispensable tools for boosting productivity. However, even the most advanced tools can present unexpected hurdles. A recent discussion on the GitHub Community forum highlighted a common frustration: Copilot's Agent mode repeatedly asking developers to manually read files, even after being granted access to an entire solution.

Developer using an AI assistant to enhance coding productivity.
Developer using an AI assistant to enhance coding productivity.

The Frustration: Copilot's Agent Mode Asking for Manual File Reads

User MManard initiated Discussion #184983, expressing dismay that GitHub Copilot in Agent mode was "repeatedly wasting prompts" by requesting manual file reads. This scenario undermines the very purpose of an AI assistant designed to streamline workflows and assist with complex tasks, especially when it comes to effective planning a software development project.

Understanding the Root Cause: Agent Mode's File Access Nuances

ImElk provided a crucial insight: Agent mode does not automatically ingest your entire solution, even when broad access is granted. Copilot typically only reasons over files that are explicitly referenced or successfully read using its internal file/search tools. This distinction is vital for developers aiming to optimize their workflow and achieve their software developer OKRs related to efficiency.

Common Reasons for Copilot's File Reading Requests:

  • Agent/Planning Tools Not Fully Enabled: Visual Studio might require a restart or specific settings to fully enable Agent mode and its planning tools.
  • Insufficient Session Permissions: Copilot might lack the necessary permissions to read certain files within the current session.
  • Implicit Prompts: The prompt provided to the agent might not explicitly instruct it on which files to read or search, leading to ambiguity.

Practical Workarounds to Enhance Copilot's Efficiency

Fortunately, several strategies can help resolve this issue and make Copilot a more effective partner in planning a software development project:

  • Verify Tooling and Restart: Ensure Agent mode and Planning tools are correctly enabled in Visual Studio. A restart of Visual Studio can often resolve initial setup glitches.
  • Explicitly Reference Files: When prompting Copilot, be specific. Instead of a general request, explicitly reference the files, folders, or symbols it needs to consider. For example, instead of "fix this bug," try "fix the bug in src/featureX/componentY.cs and tests/featureX/componentYTests.cs."
  • Instruct Copilot to Search and Read: Guide Copilot to use its tools. You can include instructions like, "Before responding, please search for relevant files in the Services directory and read their contents," or "Use your file tools to analyze the Project.csproj file." Only if tool access fails should it ask you to paste content.

Here's an example of an explicit prompt:

"I'm working on a new feature that requires modifying the 'OrderProcessor' class. Please read 'src/Services/OrderProcessor.cs' and 'src/Models/Order.cs' and suggest changes to add a 'DiscountCode' property to orders and update the processing logic."

When to Report a Bug

If these workarounds don't resolve the persistent file-reading requests, it's likely an underlying tooling bug. In such cases, reporting the issue to GitHub is crucial. Remember to include vital details:

  • Your Visual Studio version.
  • Your GitHub Copilot extension version.
  • Confirmation of whether Agent mode and Planning tools are enabled.
AI assistant helping a developer with project planning and file organization.
AI assistant helping a developer with project planning and file organization.

Conclusion: Empowering Your AI Assistant for Seamless Development

By understanding how GitHub Copilot's Agent mode interacts with your codebase and employing more explicit prompting techniques, developers can significantly reduce wasted prompts and enhance their overall productivity. This proactive approach not only streamlines individual tasks but also contributes to more efficient planning a software development project, helping teams meet their broader software developer OKRs. Leveraging AI effectively means learning its nuances, and with these insights, you can turn a point of frustration into a path for greater efficiency.